The End in the Beginning-POLL

rate the ep and tell us why!

I gave it 4 as I really enjoyed watching the episode but not as a BONES episode - Make sense?
Rating it as a BONES Episode I would give it a 1.

3,5. AU was good but AMNESIA?! Are we in some bad fanfiction, or what? Would give it even less but AU was good.

I gave it a 4.5 because it was something different. It's not like anyone thought it was real, at least I hope. I thought it was funny how they poked jabs at things from the shows run and had everyone there. And then how they had everyone there in the episode? I thought it was good. And then having the theme of protecting each other, especially when they do silly things that people do to protect each other.

I don't know if this belongs in a season finale and maybe they could have gone a little further into the forgetting thing because the rest of the episode has no purpose other than to fill 41 minutes. However I think this will be very interesting.

I eagerly await September.

SnoopGirl wrote:I gave it 4 as I really enjoyed watching the episode but not as a BONES episode - Make sense?
Rating it as a BONES Episode I would give it a 1.

Completely. It was not Bones.

I liked it. I think I may be making up my own storylines or theories to fit storylines, but I don't think he has amnesia, as I believe it was Booth's dream.

I gave it a five. No other show has lead to my friend and I jumping up and down, screaming and crying then going for a run around the block to try and calm ourselves down.

gave it a 4- because even if it felt fanfic like- got to admit loved seeing them be a couple and everyone else was so relaxed, loved cook clark!!! The amnesia thing- well I will have to see how it plays out next year. I personally think the dream he was having was what we were seeing, and it was intermingled with what she was writing, she was reading outload and someone in a coma can hear- so well that is just what I think. September can not come soon enough

3.5 - cool to see them kind of critique their own show, but the ending upset me so much it knocked off and entire skeleton

4.5 - I SO wanted to give it a 5 but I couldn't

I loved the AU world as a point of difference, and Brennan's realization of her own feelings topped it off!!

Gave it a 4.5
i thought the whole episode was so different from what i was expecting...serves me right for ready too many spoilery things.
the narrating, the fact that all their unique personalties really shon through in their "dream" persona's.
But the -.5 is for the amnesia...wtf heart...W T F??

4.5!

Hart set up everything almost to near perfection. Slapping characters into entirely new people & still having an element of normal Bones-isms.

For instance, Nigel and the facts spewing about registered guns. Wendell, and being the tough guy image. Etc.

Also, i know alot of people hated the ending. But it just set Hanson up for another season or two. As well as the opportunity to bring in more Booth's (like Booths dad).

Also I see that there could be a likelihood of them bringing Jared in as Booth's replacement. But that's just my guess on that.

Anyways, loved the episode & it's twist at the end. We'll definitely have to wait for next season to know if it was Brennan or Booth or both with that crazy club story.

Gave it five. Like I told mama, this is the first time ever that this show has managed to make me giddy. I enjoyed the AU, really, but it wasn't until I realized that it was Brennan's conscious mind concocting all this bliss that I fell madly in love and I haven't looked back.

Also, in a way, I'm actually glad about the amnesia. If he hadn't said "Who are you", the way she was looking at him, she would have kissed him back into a coma. I don't think they're ready for that just yet.

I gave it a 1.5 ....maybe..

Im really speechless after the last few minutes, but the AU was OKAY..

It was really awesome to see all the characters back, even tho they werent themselves. All the interns were awesome, and seeing Booth and Bones together was also amazing...

but the part that makes it just OKAY is....it wasnt REAL. I kinda feel like it was just taking up minutes of the show. I found myself saying and waiting...."okay, when is [he] going to wake up and get to the real stuff??"

It was dissapointing, to say the least. In my opinion, would have been much better if they would have had more 'real' and much less AU. Even tho I dont want them in bed together yet, it was sad knowing this was all fake. =(

Im glad some people are liking it tho..Maybe if I watch it again I will....I dont know. But my hopes are up for next season and where they will go with this unexpected episode.

what the hell was that?

mereva wrote:3,5. AU was good but AMNESIA?! Are we in some bad fanfiction, or what? Would give it even less but AU was good.

You were more generous that I was. I gave it a 3 and the only reason it got a 3 was the AU was good, and Emily was flippin' fantastic, but amnesia? Lame. Lame lame lame lame lame. It's lame for a fanfic, it's lame for a daytime drama, and for a show like Bones? Uber lame. HH managed to take the best procedural on TV and register an epic fail with freakin' amnesia.

RM

Did I mention it that the whole amnesia plotline was lame? 'Cause it was. Lame.