Harry Potter vs. Twilight

Please answer my poll and then tell why you chose what you chose. And, please, let's keep the responses to non-bashing. Make it like constructive critisism. Let's have to fights, please! (It's to settle an argument with a friend)

Thanks,

Bones206

I chose Harry Potter. Although I have never read Twilight nor have I seen the movie, I still rather dislike Twilight. I see the Twilight saga as romance novels with vampires and werewolves thrown in. I can't really say much on Twilight because I have not read the books or seen the movie, so I am a biased source.

I still am a loyal fan to HP, and I love it almost as much as I love Bones. I mean, J.K. puts so much description into her words, and she makes amazing intricate plot lines. Each book is different, yet the same, from the other books. So, I chose HP. I really didn't give an elaborate explanation, but, I would love to "hear" your replies!

HP 'cause honestly? I hate twilight. HP is cool, twilight is just not my thing.

RM

Harry Potter puts me to sleep everytime.

I no like Twilight... I stick with Harry!
And only vampire my heart belongs to is Angel!

Terminator 2

I had to choose Harry. I can't say as I'm a fan but I do enjoy the movies if they aren't toooo long.

Besides, I freaked when I felt myself becoming an Angel fan, so when Twilight started surfacing I told myself "Thou shalt not pay this any attention. Thou shalt not become a vampire lady!"

I tried reading the Harry Potter books and just couldn't stay in to it. I fell asleep everytime.

Twilight on the other hand, I couldn't put down.

PIMP wrote:Terminator 2

Well hell, I didn't know we could pick out own - in that case change my answer to Army of Darkness! C'mon, how do you not like a movie with Bruce Campell in it and such quotable dialogue:

Ash: Good, Bad? I'm the guy with the gun.

Evil Hag: You loved me once.
Ash: Yeah baby, well you got reeeal ugly.

Great movie man.

RM

men!

karlia wrote:men!

LMAO! Why couldn't I think of putting it so simply!!

Harry Potter.

Though in all fairness, I haven't read nor seen Twilight...but I did pick up the book in the store and read through a page. I wasn't that impressed with it, and put it back down, but that's probably not quite fair. However, when I saw the previews, and a 5 minute piece of the movie, I shuddered. That could have something to do with RP, though...I don't think he's attractive in the least. lol

flyersfan35 wrote:Harry Potter.

Though in all fairness, I haven't read nor seen Twilight...but I did pick up the book in the store and read through a page. I wasn't that impressed with it, and put it back down, but that's probably not quite fair. However, when I saw the previews, and a 5 minute piece of the movie, I shuddered. That could have something to do with RP, though...I don't think he's attractive in the least. lol

There is zero chance that I'll pick up the Twilight book(s), but I do remember seeing a clip of it somewhere early on, with him flying through the trees and swooping down on her. I was all kinds of "Oh My!" wanting to see it. I don't know if I'd enjoy it really, maybe YES, maybe not, but I WILL NOT GO SEE IT!

I will remain true to Angel. (That actually sounds kind of sick! ) Oh well, sometimes the truth ain't pretty!

Honestly I like both, and it depends on what mood I'm in as to which I prefer. Also, I don't really compare the two at all. They are two entirely different worlds. I mean, had they made Angela or Jessica a witch or something then maybe. (From Twilight I mean), but otherwise it's not the same comparison.

As far as vampires themselves go, of course Angel is number one. BUT...if it's current? I would pick True Blood over Twilight. I love True Blood.

Voted for Twilight.

HP book were better than twilight books, (due their poor grammar..which i hate!!) But to me they kind of lost after the first 4 books.

BUT......Really loved the whole twilight series, and the movies.